The Alternative for Germany has chosen a former World Cup winner for a presidential election it is almost certain to lose. By nominating Thomas Berthold, the right-wing party is trading a realistic bid for Germany’s highest office for a chance to put its political language in front of the country.
Berthold, 62, was part of West Germany’s 1990 World Cup-winning team. The AfD and Berthold have presented him as an independent candidate who could unite Germans. His opponents see something very different: a familiar public figure whose positions echo the party’s anti-establishment rhetoric and whose nomination tests how far those ideas can be carried into the symbolism of the state.
The candidacy was reported on 16 November 2026 and immediately drew criticism from the Social Democratic Party, the Christian Democratic Union and Christian Social Union bloc, and the Greens. Politicians from those parties dismissed it as an absurd idea and questioned Berthold’s suitability for an office associated with national unity and the defence of Germany’s democratic order.
A candidate chosen for the argument
The controversy centres on Berthold’s public record as described by his political critics. They point to his participation in demonstrations by opponents of coronavirus restrictions and to statements they interpret as denying or minimising the pandemic and climate change. They have also associated his rhetoric with anti-Semitic narratives, ideas linked to the so-called Citizens of the Reich movement and conspiracy theories about a “shadow government”.
Those claims form part of the political dispute over his suitability and are not independently assessed here. Their significance lies in the contrast critics draw between the expectations attached to the presidency and a candidate they say has questioned the legitimacy of established institutions.
The Federal President does not run the government. The office is nevertheless designed to represent the constitutional order and the country as a whole, with the holder expected to play an integrating role during moments of political strain. That makes the choice of candidate more consequential symbolically than the election arithmetic might suggest.
Critics argue that putting a figure associated with conspiracy narratives and suspicion of state institutions into the presidential contest risks making those views appear more respectable. The AfD gains precisely the platform its parliamentary strength cannot provide: a national debate about the meaning of Germany’s political system, conducted around a candidate known far beyond party politics.
The “independent” label under pressure
Berthold’s supposed independence is central to the AfD’s presentation. A former international footballer offers a recognisable face without the baggage of a conventional party career. His sporting past allows the AfD to frame the nomination as a popular intervention by someone close to ordinary citizens rather than another manoeuvre by professional politicians.
Berthold himself and the party leadership have stressed his non-partisan status. Their opponents reject that description, pointing to reported references to a “shadow government” and “puppet politicians”, alongside his positions on the pandemic and climate change. They say the language overlaps with themes used by AfD leaders and therefore undermines the claim that he stands outside the party’s political project.
An overlap in rhetoric does not, by itself, establish that Berthold is controlled by the AfD. It does explain why the description of him as an independent World Cup champion has been met with scepticism. The label serves a clear communications purpose: it lets the party attach its message to a nationally recognisable figure without putting forward one of its own senior politicians.
The decision has also prompted a less flattering interpretation of the party’s internal strength. Critics say the AfD lacks an established politician with the authority and broad public credibility required for the presidency. Instead of nominating a leading figure from its own ranks, it has turned to a former athlete whose national profile was built on achievements decades ago.
That criticism is difficult to separate from the nomination’s intended audience. The AfD is not only addressing the delegates who will cast the votes. It is also speaking to potential supporters who may respond more readily to a sporting celebrity than to the party’s parliamentary leadership. A candidate who cannot win can still generate attention, widen the party’s reach and reinforce its claim to represent people outside the political establishment.
The numbers leave Berthold little room
Germany’s president is not elected directly by the public. The decision belongs to the Federal Convention, made up of members of the Bundestag and an equal number of delegates from the states. A candidate needs an absolute majority.
The AfD does not have enough support in that body to reach the threshold. The other major parties have also ruled out cooperation with it and agreed to back Ilse Aigner, the president of Bavaria’s state parliament. Aigner is widely expected to win the vote on 30 January, succeed Frank-Walter Steinmeier and become the first woman to hold the federal presidency.
That leaves Berthold with no credible route to victory. The nomination is therefore better understood as a political signal than as a conventional campaign. It allows the AfD to place its themes in a contest normally associated with constitutional continuity, while giving the party an opportunity to depict the established parties as a united bloc determined to keep it away from the country’s highest institutions.
The strategy carries a tension of its own. The AfD can use Berthold’s fame to present itself as more socially rooted and less confined to the world of party politics. Yet the controversy over his views also sharpens the question of whether the message being amplified is compatible with the integrative role of the presidency.
The result on 30 January is unlikely to settle that question. Aigner’s expected victory will confirm the AfD’s lack of the alliances needed to elect a president. The more important contest will take place beyond the Federal Convention: whether Berthold’s profile brings new voters towards the party, or instead makes the distance between the AfD and Germany’s central state institutions harder to ignore.
Read the Tagesspiegel report.