Manchester City ousts Newcastle United from Carabao Cup
Newcastle United’s reign as Carabao Cup holders came to a crushing end on Wednesday evening as Manchester City swept them aside 3-1 at the Etihad Stadium, sealing a comprehensive 5-1 aggregate victory in the semi-final, reports BritPanorama.
The Magpies, who claimed the trophy last season by defeating Liverpool in the final, were thoroughly outclassed by Pep Guardiola’s side across both legs. City dominated the match, with Omar Marmoush scoring twice in a devastating first-half display that effectively killed off any hope of a Newcastle comeback.
Marmoush opened the scoring in the seventh minute when Dan Burn’s attempted clearance ricocheted off him and into the net. His second goal arrived midway through the half, heading home from close range after Antoine Semenyo’s cross was cleared directly to him. Tijjani Reijnders completed the first-half demolition three minutes later, finishing coolly after Burn’s tackle on Semenyo inadvertently played him through.
Newcastle managed a brief response in the second half, with substitute Anthony Elanga cutting inside before finding the far corner for the Magpies’ sole goal. However, the heavy defeat has intensified criticism of manager Eddie Howe, with growing calls from supporters for his dismissal after five years at the helm.
Frustration among fans centres on a perceived lack of progress, with many accusing the club of stagnation under Howe’s leadership. Tactical decisions during the match drew particular ire, especially his choice to field a defensive five-man backline when Newcastle needed to score twice to advance to the final. Critics argue that this cautious approach against top-tier opposition reflects a failure to demonstrate sufficient ambition in crucial fixtures.
Supporters have taken to social media to express their discontent. One fan stated, “Eddie Howe greatest manager we’ve had in a generation, but it’s time to go now, we’re not going anywhere, just sitting stagnating.” Another lamented, “Eddie Howe has sucked the life out of the team this season. Need 2 goals to get to a final – play a back 5. Just rolls over for the bigger teams.”
As the fallout continues from this defeat, it is clear that questions remain not just about Newcastle’s immediate future, but also about the direction of their ambition. In football, the margins are often razor-thin, but the pressure for decisive action in the face of stagnation can be overwhelming, and fans will be watching closely.
