Jamie Carragher’s U-turn on Casemiro met with mixed reactions from Manchester United fans
Manchester United fans have refused to accept Jamie Carragher’s U-turn on Casemiro, with the Sky Sports pundit admitting he was wrong about the Brazil international, reports BritPanorama.
Back in May 2024, Carragher sensationally stated that the football had ‘left’ Casemiro following a poor performance in a 4-0 defeat away at Crystal Palace. Since that moment, Casemiro has rebounded strongly, emerging as a pivotal figure for United once again. In a recent match against Fulham, he played an integral role, scoring the opening goal with a header from a precise Bruno Fernandes cross.
Following this performance, Casemiro further contributed by assisting Matheus Cunha’s goal, which secured a 2-0 advantage for the Red Devils. Post-match, Carragher praised Casemiro’s return to form, even conceding that the midfielder has every right to respond to his earlier criticism. “It is now fair to say the football has not left him,” Carragher remarked.
He went on to elaborate on Casemiro’s recent performances, stating, “Considering what he’s producing this season in the Premier League, and not just Fulham at home, you think what he did last week against Arsenal away and Manchester City at home.” Carragher added, “Casemiro is well within his rights to, if he wants to come back at me and say, ‘leave the punditry before the punditry’s left you!’ He could definitely get one of those back in. Credit to him, he looks a completely different player.”
Some United fans, however, remain skeptical about Carragher’s reversed stance. Comments on social media included sentiments like, “We have left Jamie Carragher in 2025. He’s absolutely washed,” and critiques on his previous criticism of other players as well. Another fan suggested that if Carragher truly regrets his past assessment, he should publicly apologize for what many viewed as disrespectful commentary.
Conversely, other supporters expressed approval of Carragher’s admission, noting, “It’s actually embarrassing Jamie Carragher talks more sense than our legends and admits when he was wrong.” Another added, “At least Jamie is being honest. Kudos to him.” Many viewed Carragher’s candidness as commendable, recognising it as a hallmark of maturity in sports discourse.
As United looks to maintain its momentum, Casemiro will aim to continue his impressive form against Tottenham this Saturday. The teams previously drew 2-2 earlier this season, promising an engaging rematch.
In football, the narratives shift rapidly, and while Carragher’s realisation speaks volumes, it also illustrates the delicate balance between scrutiny and appreciation that defines the sport. The opinions on his commentary serve as a reminder of how easily athletes and pundits can traverse the fine line between criticism and support.
